With half of the 2008 NFL season in the books, it's time to revisit the list of the most collectible players from this year's rookie class. Some of my original picks have been as good as advertised (hey Matt Ryan!), while others aren't even sniffing playing time (sorry Brian Brohm).
Several running backs have made splashes, which isn't that shocking. What has been a pleasant surprise is the play of quarterbacks and receivers, as those are harder positions to learn at the NFL level.
I'll do one more update to my list at the end of the season, but here's who I'd most want to see coming out of packs right now:
1. Matt Ryan, QB, Atlanta Falcons
Even if the Falcons lose every game during the second half of the 2008 season, one would have to consider Matt Ryan's debut a smashing success. He's averaged about 200 yards a game and thrown more touchdowns than interceptions through eight games. More importantly, he's helped Atlanta look much better much faster than most people anticipated.
Any hand-wringing Falcons fans did over using a high pick on Ryan should be done. He has the look of a winner.
2. Matt Forte, RB, Chicago Bears
Painful memories of the Cedric Benson experiment faded quickly thanks to this second-rounder from Tulane. Though he's not the fastest or strongest back in this class, he may be the most well-rounded, able to run, catch and pick up the blitz
Forte also plays in a great collecting market in Chicago, which gives him the edge over several other successful draft classmates. This is a guy the Bears fans hope they will be watching well into the next decade
3. Chris Johnson, RB, Tennessee Titans
The Titans have taken the NFL by storm, surprising everyone by sprinting to an 8-0 record through nine weeks. Johnson has been a big reason why, adding an extra element of speed to an already potent ground game.
Though he operates in a time-sharing arrangement with LenDale White, Johnson was fifth in the NFL in rushing after nine weeks and led all of the top 20 runners in average yards per carry. Only the low profile Tennessee market and his relative anonymity coming out of college keep him from ranking even higher on this list.
4. Joe Flacco, QB, Baltimore Ravens
Flacco got Baltimore's starting job at the beginning of the season almost by default, but he's showing no signs of letting it go. He hasn't exactly ignited an offensive explosion for the Ravens, but he's been heady and shown more athleticism than some expected - like when he caught a 43-yard pass against the Raiders.
With the Baltimore defense looking scary again and a strong running game (done by a committee that includes fellow rookie Ray Rice), all Flacco has to do is not kill his team's chances with mistakes. He's succeeded for the most part and looks like a good one to bet on in the long term.
5. DeSean Jackson, WR, Philadelphia Eagles
Not too many receivers, especially small ones, make significant contributions in their first NFL seasons. Jackson is bucking that trend with his performance, adding punch to the Philly return game and quickly earning the trust of Donovan McNabb.
He still has some maturing to do, as evidenced by the fact that he flipped the football away before he crossed the goal line for his first NFL touchdown. Jackson's physical skills are already at an NFL level though, and could be at an All-Pro level before too long.
6. Darren McFadden, RB, Oakland Raiders
McFadden has slipped a bit from his top spot on this list, but that's due in large part to nagging injuries and another dreadful season for the Raiders. He's delivered some bursts when called upon, averaging 5.1 yards on his first 77 carries.
So it hasn't been all bad for McFadden, and he remains a great pull to hold for the long haul. Still, you can't help but wonder if he looks enviously at the fun Ronnie Brown is having in the Wildcat in Miami since that was his baby in college.
7. Felix Jones, RB, Dallas Cowboys
Jones used his speed to burst onto the scene like a bolt of lightning in the Cowboys' first few games, but an injury has him sidelined at the season's midway point. Marion Barber hasn't seemed quite as effective without Felix to provide a breather and has to be rooting for the rookie to return soon.
Out of sight can mean out of mind in the hobby, but making big plays in Big D is a good way to win back fans in a hurry. It will be interesting to see if Jones - and the Cowboys, for that matter - can salvage something from the second half of a season that started with so much promise.
8. Steve Slaton, RB, Houston Texans
Many experts doubted Slaton's game would translate to the NFL, but he's looked very comfortable as a pro so far. Among rookies, only Chris Johnson and Matt Forte ran for more yards through nine weeks, and Slaton had more rushing touchdowns than either of them.
One problem: except for a brief flirtation with David Carr back in 2002, the hobby doesn't exactly go ga-ga for Texans - even stud receiver Andre Johnson is underappreciated among collectors. That could mean some uphill sledding for Slaton but could also mean some nice bargains for those seeking his top rookie cards.
9. Jonathan Stewart, RB, Carolina Panthers
It's not that Stewart has been bad, it's just that other rookie runners have been better. It hasn't helped that teammate DeAngelo Williams has been a top-10 back, making Stewart the change of pace instead of the other way around.
Media members covering the Panthers still expect Stewart to be a big part of the offense in the season's second half, and the team's playoff prospects are looking pretty good too. That may give Stewart the extra face time he needs to move back up this list.
10. Eddie Royal, WR, Denver Broncos
Worthy candidates for this final spot include running back Ray Rice, receiver Donnie Avery and linebacker Jerod Mayo. Royal gets bonus points though, because many experts figured he'd simply be a kick returner and occasional contributor when the Broncos went four-wide.
Instead, Royal has been a main cog in the Denver passing game from Week One, using his quickness to get open on short routes while defenses concentrate on Brandon Marshall. No rookie has more catches through nine weeks and only DeSean Jackson has more receiving yards.








